I feel like I’m going against everything I thought I knew about personal branding.
You know the golden rule. Be consistent. Have the same voice, same message, same vibe everywhere you show up, blah blah. Someone should be able to find you on any platform and INSTANTLY know it’s you.
I believe in that rule so much that it’s basically my day job. I spend my days making sure a brand sounds like the same brand on the website, in the ads, in the emails and on social.
BUT. When it comes to me? I’ve noticed I’m a slightly different version of myself on every platform.
And honestly... I like it that way.
The Instagram version of me
Instagram me moves fast. She has about two seconds to earn your attention before you keep scrolling, so she leads with the hook, gets to the point, and wraps it up before your coffee gets cold. Though mine will always be cold, because well, mom life.
That’s where I share how I’m building my creative business, plus the marketing and content tips I’ve picked up along the way. Though lately, I’ve been trying to make it more of a visual diary. Slower clips, ordinary moments, the little stuff that makes up a regular week.
The goal is to gently nudge parents to pick up the camera and capture the “ordinary” days with their kids before they grow up. Because they really do go fast.
Here’s the thing though. I don’t show my kids online.
So I’m trying to make content about capturing your kids’ childhood... without actually showing mine. It’s a puzzle I’m still working through. How do you tell a story about the moments that matter most when the people at the center of those moments stay off camera?
Anyways, different story for another time.
Ok back to the point of this article.. Then you layer the algorithm on top of all that. Hooks, trends, watch time, posting at the “right” time, the audio everyone’s using this week.
If you ask me how I feel about it? Overstimulated, lol.
I don’t hate it. It’s been REALLY good to me, as I’ve also met some great people and have landed paid partnerships. But it asks for a version of me that’s always a little bit “on.”
And then there’s here
Transparently, I started this Substack as an extension of whatever I was building on Instagram. Another place to share the same stuff, just longer.
What I didn’t plan for was you.
I never expected such a warm, welcoming community here and it honestly caught me completely off guard.
Here, I feel like I can talk freely. I can be my actual self without checking the analytics, chasing a trend, or wondering if anyone will even bother reading these articles.
I write Substack Notes without expecting anyone to hit like or respond. Half the time it’s just a thought I wanted to get out of my head. And then someone does respond, and it’s always the kindest message.
It’s a strange feeling for someone who’s spent a decade looking at engagement and conversion rates. Over here, the engagement just feels like... people. Talking. Being nice to each other on the internet. Being HUMAN.
So is that bad branding?
By the textbook, maybe.
But I keep coming back to this. We’re already different versions of ourselves in real life. You probably don’t talk to your best friend the same way you talk in a work meeting. You’re not less “you” in either room. Each room just brings out a different side.
And maybe platforms are just rooms.
Instagram is the busy cafe where you catch up in quick bursts. Substack is the kitchen table after everyone’s asleep, when you finally get to say the thing you’ve been thinking about all day.
Neither version of me is fake. The Instagram version is real. The version writing this is real. They just have different amounts of time and different people listening.
What I think actually matters for a personal brand isn’t sounding identical everywhere. It’s that your values stay the same. The things I care about don’t change when I’m switching between apps. On both, I’m building something of my own without burning out, protecting my family’s privacy, noticing the ordinary days, and being honest with you about all of it.
The tone can vary and change, but the heart shouldn’t.
I’ll be honest, I haven’t fully figured out the Instagram side. The visual diary thing is still a work in progress, and I don’t know yet how slow I can go in a place built for fast. So that’s TBD. Maybe I’ll share more of it here since it might resonate with the parenting community I’ve connected with.
But one thing I know is that: I don’t want to force this space to become a longer version of a reel. Here gets to be its own thing.
If you’ve been feeling this too
If you’re building something online and you’ve felt the pressure to be one polished, perfectly consistent person everywhere... consider this your permission to let loose a little.
You’re allowed to be quicker in one place and softer in another. You’re allowed to find that one platform just feels more like home. And you’re allowed to lean into that instead of apologizing for it.
You’re not doing it wrong. You’re just human.
I would love to know: do you feel like a different version of yourself on different platforms? Which one feels most like you?
With love,
Sally




This is so interesting (and a huge part of what I’m building!). People aren’t niches, and they aren’t brand voices, and they don't do just one thing. People are complicated and messy and they are different depending on the people they’re with, the places they go, and the way they feel on any given day. Love this perspective - SUBSCRIBED!